I find this to be the most difficult of all the posts we have had since I didn't know what was being said in the film. I considered watching the movie now with subtitles but decided not to wait for the library to get the movie in since this usually takes several days. Not having seen her in her American home it is very difficult for me to compare her new culture. I didn't feel that she had to adapt too much, she already spoke fluent Spanish because of her mother. She met many new people, her grandfather and her aunt and uncle and cousins(?) I don't know if she had met them previously. She seemed to easily make friends with the children she came in contact with. I didn't find the beginning scene where her hat was taken to be very different from any child moving to a new area, whether it was a new city, state or country. Having been a child whose parents moved around a lot, I frequently was in a situation where I had to make new friends and start over again. I did think that the hardest part she had to adapt to was being without her father and knowing he was at war and in constant danger. She seemed relatively happy while her mother was alive. Her mother apparently was able to read and write in English because after she died she had to have Maruca's help to write to her father. I am not sure if she attended church before the move or what religion she practiced but this was an obvious change for her as she seemed somewhat out of place during communion. Also, the revolution going on around her must have been confusing too. After her mother died she must have felt very alone, it was good that she felt so close to her grandfather. I am not sure what happened to her father, and assume that she was returning to America in the end to be with him. The film seemed to be very touching and I probably will watch it with subtitles, just to see what I missed.
Angela, I agree this film was difficult to screen. I liked your thoughts about Carol's father being in constant danger. I was relieved that he wasn't killed in front of her. I was afraid that at the scene at the damm, her father was going to be shot. I spoke to Angel after class and asked what happened to Carol's father. I was told that he was returned to the war. I also felt that Carol adjusted well to her new surroundings. I, too want to view this film with English subtitles.
ReplyDeleteOne week left and this class will be finished. We all have to admit, we have learned a little more about cultural diversity.
Great thoughts about it. It seems that at the end her father went back to the war. I am glad you are all going to include this in your must-see list with English subtitles.
ReplyDeleteI agree it is difficult to screen not knowing the language. I thought Carol was a remarkable young lady. She seemed to care for everyone. I think she was upset at the boy who shot the bird with the slingshot because she didn't want it hurt. I was impressed with how much she cared. I thought it was so kind of her to want to teach the servant girl how to read. She did seem so worried about her father and treasured the scrapbook with the picture of them together. I thought it was so touching when she said the now I lay me down to sleep prayer and then said goodnight to the picture of ther father.
ReplyDeletesue davish
If Carol's father went back to war at the end, where was Carol going?
ReplyDelete